pCall us! (860) 529-1737 Hablamos Español

Wethersfield, Connecticut

Pay Your Bill

Listed below please find a list of carriers and their billing department phone numbers, online billing sites, and mailing addresses. For additional billing questions, call the office or email service@oldelibertyins.com.

American Modern Ins

1-800-543-2644
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
American Modern Ins Group, PO Box 5323, Cincinnati, OH 45201-5323



AmTrust

877.528.7878
Pay Online / More Info

For payments regarding direct bill installments, down payments, quotes, audits or claims:
AmTrust North America, P.O. Box 6939, Cleveland, OH 44101-1939

For payments and correspondence regarding MSA, agency billed, return commissions, PAYO or premium finance:
AmTrust North America, P.O. Box 5849, Cleveland, OH 44101-0849



Arbella

1-617-328-2800
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Arbella Ins, PO Box 55392, Boston, MA 02205-5392



Arrowhead

Pay Online / More Info



Bunker Hill

866-322-2442
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Bunker Hill Insurance Company, Payment Processing Center, PO Box 55934, Boston, MA 02205



Chubb

1-800-682-4822
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Chubb Ins Co., Attn: Cash Unit, 202 Halls Mill Rd., Whitehouse Stn, NJ 08889



Dairyland

1-800-526-4252
Auto: Pay Online / More Info
Motorcycle: Pay Online / More Info

Mail payments to:
Dairyland Ins, PO Box 8030, Stevens Point, WI 54481-8030



Encompass

1-800-262-9262 option 1
Pay Online / More Info



Fireman’s Fund

1-800-261-9497
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Fireman's Fund, Dept. 0002, Palatine, IL 60055-0002

Foremost Specialty

1-800-527-3905
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Foremost Ins Group, Premium Process Center, PO Box 0915, Carol Stream, IL 60132



GUARD Insurance Group

Pay Online / More Info



Hagerty

Pay Online / More Info



Hanover

1-800-922-8427
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
The Hanover Ins Group., Attn: Direct Bill, PO Box 580045, Charlotte, NC 28258-0045

Overnight address:
The Hanover Insurance Company, Attn: Retail Lockbox (PO Box 580045), 5130 Parkway Plaza Blvd, Charlotte, NC 28217



Harleysville

1-800-338-8301
Pay Online / More Info

Mail new business payment to:
Harleysville Insurance, Payment Processing Center,355 Maple Ave, Harleysville, PA 19441-0002

Recurring billing address:
Harleysville Insurance, PO Box 37712, Philadelphia, PA 19101



Hartford

1-800-771-8557
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
The Hartford, Direct Bill, PO Box 5556, Hartford, CT 06102



Kemper

866-675-3345
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Kemper Preferred, PO Box 70839, Charlotte, NC 28272-0839



MetLife

800-680-3354
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
MetLife Auto & Home, PO Box 41753, Philadelphia, PA 19101-1753

Overnight Mail payments to:
Remitco, MetLife Auto & Home, Lockbox 941753, 2080 Cabot Blvd. West, Langhorne, PA 19047



National Grange Mutual

800-611-0958
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
The Main Street America Group, P.O. Box 2004, Keene, NH 03431

Peerless

1-603-352-3221
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Peerless Insurance Co., Direct Bill Dept. PO Box 703, Keene, NH 03431



Pilgrim

Pay Online / More Info



Plymouth Rock

866-353-6292
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Plymouth Rock Assurance Company, Payment Processing Center, PO Box 55933, Boston, MA 02205



Preferred Mutual

1-888-511-2455
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Preferred Mutual Insurance, Direct Bill, One Preferred Way, New Berlin, NY 13411



Preferred Mutual


Pay Online / More Info



Providence Mutual

1-877-763-1800
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
The Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Company, PO Box 6066, Providence, RI 02940-6066



Safeco

1-877-566-6001
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Attn: Payment Processing Department, Safeco Insurance Companies, PO Box 6476, Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476



Tower Insurance Group

1-877-883-6599
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Tower Group Companies, PO Box 371898, Pittsburgh, PA 15251-7898



Travelers

1-800-842-8574
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Travelers, PO Box 660317, Dallas, TX 75266-0317

Overnight mail:
Travelers, Attn: BI 660317, 1500 Dragon Street, Suite A, Dallas, TX 75207



Utica First

1-800-456-4556
Pay Online / More Info

Mail payment to:
Utica First, PO Box 851, Utica, NY 13503